Archived Post
Round-ups
Contains: Affiliate Links, Sample Provided
Christine |
Makeup Geek Eyeshadows ($6.00 for 0.068 oz.) are available in a slew of shades ranging from go-to neutrals to pops of color. Here’s a list of the best Makeup Geek eyeshadows I’ve tried 🙂 This list will continue to update as they release other permanent shades–if they do well enough to break into the top 25! You can also see how the formula has done overall as well as see how readers have rated it!
What are your go-to Makeup Geek eyeshadows?
Top 25 Makeup Geek Eyeshadows
Explore Temptalia
We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more!
Here are some useful resources for you:
Compare Any Two
Curious how two shades compare to each other? Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches!
Comments that do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to participate respectfully. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an off-topic question, or need technical support, please contact us!
Please help us streamline the comments' section and be more efficient: double-check the post above for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't answered already. Comments alerting us to typos or small errors in the post are appreciated (!) but will typically be removed after errors are fixed (unless a response is needed).
We appreciate enthusiasm for new releases but ask readers to please hold questions regarding if/when a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. We don't want to set expectations and then disappoint readers as even products that are swatched don't always end up being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Thank you for understanding!
Comments on this post are closed.
Indya
Very Deep, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Very Oily skin. »View Indya Full Profile
Oooooo thanks for this. How do you think this compare to the Mac shadows that just decreased to the same price (generally, overall)?
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
An A is an A is an A, regardless of price. Like all products, there are hits and there are misses, so it just depends on the shade you’re interested in!
Lee
I would go with Mac. Mac doesn’t lie about ingredients and they have better customer service overall. If you don’t like it, you can return it.
You make a valid point, Lee. I don’t like buying from a brand that doesn’t have an exchange or return policy, generally speaking.
CatG
That’s so interesting. I’ve had way better customer service experiences with Makeup Geek than Mac! I guess it just depends.
PrNoir
I recently purchased a brush from MUG that was very scratchy. I e-mailed customer service the night I got the package about the issue and within 2 days, they wrote back. They did ask for a picture and wanted to know what was wrong with the item, and 2 days after that I had a tracking number for a replacement item. They didn’t even ask me to send back the old one. I’ve been pretty happy about dealing with their customer service dept.
Nike
To my mind the MUG shadows are waayyy better.
Here in Germany MAC refill pans are 15€, which is like 17$ atm – insanely overpriced for the quality you get.
I started to buy MUG after the fifth MAC eyeshadow I bought that was hardly pigmented.
Now that they are the same price (at least in the US) I would always prefer MUG over MAC though.
Mardi
MUG is cruelty free, MAC isn’t.
Nicole
Light Medium, Yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Nicole Full Profile
This is really helpful! Thank you! 🙂
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Glad I could help, Nicole!
These SO helpful Christine! I need to jump on the Makeup Geel bandwagon! I got the Viseart Paris Nudes palette because you like it so much and I LOVE it! Every color is so beautiful! 🙂
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Aw, thank you Divya! 🙂
Melissa
Light, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Oily skin. »View Melissa Full Profile
Funnily enough I found a MUG eye-shadow retailer where I live about 2-3 days ago. So this round-up came out right on time 😀 Now I can finally try the illustrious shadows…
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Ooh, nice!
Diane
Very Deep, Neutral undertones. Combination skin. »View Diane Full Profile
Cosmopolitan is my all time favorite , it’s so pigmented ; Coco bear is a favorite too , i love cinderella for highlight and love also bitten and homecoming if i want a cooler look.
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Cocoa Bear is great!
Stephanie
I love Mesmerized foil shadow, bitten matte shadow, and the Blacklight duo chrome shadow.
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Nice picks, Stephanie!
Nancy T
Medium, Olive, neutral undertones. Combination skin. »View Nancy T Full Profile
Some of these look quite appealing. But with all that’s taken place with this brand lately, I don’t know that I would feel 100% comfortable purchasing their products. This is just my own honest opinion.
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
I totally understand, Nancy! 🙂
KJH
To use the current cliche, I feel ya. I have a big Z plus of shadows and 4-5 blushes. Marlena and Cora (vintageortacky) were my original blogs to read/check reviews, until….. It started long before MUG outgrew their lady bloomers and started flying too close to the sun. How’s that for mixing metaphors? There was no critical eye. They loved everything, even $^€k¥ stuff. No discernment, no refinement, no SYSTEM. Then mug got big time greedy and full of themselves. Not sure I’ll ever get another MUG product. Greed breeds unscrupulous behavior.
Rachel R.
Lightest, Neutral undertones. Normal-to-Oily skin. »View Rachel R. Full Profile
Same here. And I haven’t been very happy with the quality of the shadows I bought. None of them were these shades, though.
PrNoir
I’m pretty new to MUG brand, so I guess I am unaware. If you don’t mind me asking, what has been taking place with the brand, that makes you uncomfortable with them? Thank you
Ginny
My absolute favorites are a few of the mattes. Cocoa Bear, Creme Brulee, Desert Sands, Beaches and Cream, and Unexpected. Corrupt is very pigmented but it migrates all over my eye lid 🙁
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Migrates! Does it crease or transfer or just… moves?
Ginny
I usually wear it as an upper lash liner, either on its own or to smoke out a liquid liner. Later it will end up bleeding through to my lower lashline, moreso than your typical mascara does, and it will end up transferring further up on my lid from my outer corners/wings. I guess it is the way my eye is shaped (my lid folds over a bit on itself in my outer corner, but I do not consider my eyes to be hooded, they are pretty “typical”) and that my lids are slightly oily. I prefer UD Blackout. Corrupt is still a great black, though!
Christine
Ahh, gotcha! 🙂 That must be so frustrating!
Marie-Estelle
Very Light, Pink, strong pink undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Marie-Estelle Full Profile
What nice of you to sum up the best of a brand! I might complete my little MUG collection :3
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Yay!
CatG
I have all of these except three…. I love Makeup Geek… my favorite eyeshadows 😛 😛
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Ooh, very nice 🙂
KJH
By the look of the Z, it’s sensuous, unicorn, shimmer mint, cupcake, and rockstar. They seem to be the most used, not nec. the best liked. Disappointments: stealth, prom night, shoreline. 2 or more aren’t in that Z; didn’t look. I like Barcelona beach and high tea as crease shades.. Moondust is one of the only shades I ever bought that lost its binder & turned into Bare Minerals! Chickadee and Razzleberry are somewhat unusual. I do have issues with MUG now. Replied to Nancy.
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Rockstar is a cool one. Barcelona Beach-type shades should be more common across brands.
Brooke
Light Medium, Neutral undertones. Combination skin. »View Brooke Full Profile
I’m so glad you posted this! I’ve been trying to decide which ones to pick up!
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
No problem, Brooke!
Nell
I own a bunch of them and in my honest opinion, they are rather “meh”. Just too powdery. They are by no chance bad and used to be a good alternative to more pricy shadows out there….until MAC put there old price back. Now they cost same as MAC, and they positioned themselves as “MAC but cheaper”, i don’t see any reason to get MUG eyeshadows. And on top, their half-baked launches and $45 palette are rather disappointing as well as the whole ingredients issue and deleting customers’ comments and complaints. Nope from my wallet.
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
I’ve found both lines to have hits and misses – they’re definitely not all good! 🙂
Bonnie
Light Medium, Olive, neutral undertones. Combination skin. »View Bonnie Full Profile
They’re still a great alternative for those who buy only cruelty-free products!
Nell
Don’t they use carmine in their shadows? And also, i am no expert but i am wondering, who certified them? I haven’t seen any official logo of official cruelty-free orgs. Eg i use Kevin Murphy hair products and every bottle comes with a bunny logo – this is peta logo. MUG only talks about being cruelty free, but there is no evidence or logo.
Bonnie
Yes they use carmine but that’s not a requirement for being cruelty-free. You might be thinking about Vegan makeup. You can’t use carmine in Vegan makeup since carmine is made from an acid derived from a beetle. They don’t have a cruelty-free certification but many brands don’t. That’s just something some cruelty-free brands pay extra for, to be certified by PETA or another animal advocacy group. But I give brands the benefit of the doubt when they say they’re cruelty-free, because there are many watch dog groups who check up on this sort of thing and we would have heard about it if they tested on animals but claimed to be cruelty-free. And it would be very very stupid of them to go that route (claiming to be cruelty-free but testing on animals) because once discovered they would lose all their credibility as a brand and lose most of their business. I personally don’t buy only cruelty-free makeup, just because some of my favorite brands are not cruelty-free. But I really wish that all brands were cruelty-free because there’s no good reason to test on animals in this day and age IMO.
Susan Parker
Holy smokes! What a weird coincidence… I just placed an order for nine MUG eyeshadows yesterday! I did, of course, consult your reviews and swatches beforehand. ?
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Which nine did you get, Susan?
Susan Parker
Duochromes: Steampunk and Typhoon. Regular: Drama Queen, Rapunzel, Shimma Shimma and Day Dreamer. Foiled: Fantasy, Jester and Magic Act. I also bought a Makeup Geek Travel Vault Palette to store and protect the shadows.
Genevieve
Lightest, Pink undertones. Dry skin. »View Genevieve Full Profile
Thank you so much for this list – MUG have amazing eye shadows, beautiful colours, great ratings and at a fabulous price. What’s not to love?
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
My pleasure, Genevieve!
Bonnie
Light Medium, Olive, neutral undertones. Combination skin. »View Bonnie Full Profile
LOVE this post so much!!! it made it super easy to add MUG shadows with good grades to my list that I need to get! Thank you!!
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Thank you, Bonnie!! 🙂
Fran
Light Plus, Pink undertones. Combination skin. »View Fran Full Profile
I wonder why most of the best-performing eyeshadows are warm colors. Some of it must be difficulty in formulation (it seems like blues and blue-violets must be hard to make well, since so few brands succeed), but I wonder if some if it is lack of interest in cool colors on the part of the marketing people. Is it really that hard to sell cool colors?
Christine
User Christine BlogUser Christine TwitterUser Christine FacebookUser Christine InstagramUser Christine Tumblr
Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Normal-to-Dry skin. »View Christine Full Profile
Their line is mostly warm colors, IMO, particularly for neutrals!
Fran
They have a few really cool cool colors, though, that keep attracting me 😉
Astrild
Peach Smoothie, Barcelona Beach, Cocoa Bear and Frappe are probable my most used eyeshadows of all brands. I have more MUG eyeshadows and I like them a lot.
We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get behind and appreciate your patience! 🙂 If you have general feedback, product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please contact us directly. Thank you for your patience!
